What Are the Best Toilet Safety Rails in 2019

An old woman leaning on the best toilet safety rails in her bathroom.

How steady are you around the bathroom? It may not be something that many of us think about, but there are a number of different reasons why our mobility can become a problem—either as a temporary or an ongoing situation.

Like kitchens, bathrooms pose particular problems in terms of health and safety. Hopefully we all know that water doesn’t mix well with electricity—that’s why we have strict safety laws. But water can also increase the likelihood of slips and falls—especially combined with a smooth surface, like bathroom tiles.

It’s not usually a big problem for most people. When our bodies are functioning well, our natural balance receptors work hard to keep us upright and stop us from falling. But when we’re not on top form, a little help and support is a great idea to keep us safe from harm.

Toilet safety rails are very simple but effective products that can help to improve stability and mobility in the bathroom. Here’s all you need to know about them, and how to pick out the best toilet safety rails around.

Product
Details
Our Rating
Our #1 Rated
Stand-Alone Toilet Safety Rail

Drive Medical

Stand-Alone Toilet Safety Rail

4.3 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category

Click for price

  • One-piece compact toilet safety rail.
  • Adjustable from 26 to 31 inches.
  • Weight capacity up to 300 pounds.

HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #1 Rated

4.3 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category


Our #2 Rated
Guardian Toilet Safety Rail

Medline

Guardian Toilet Safety Rail

4.2 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category

Click for price

  • One-piece compact toilet safety rail.
  • Adjustable from 26 to 31 inches.
  • Maximum user weight capacity 250 pounds.

HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #2 Rated

4.2 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category


Our #3 Rated
Deluxe Safety Toilet Rail

Vaunn

Deluxe Safety Toilet Rail

3.8 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category

Click for price

  • One-piece free-standing toilet safety rail.
  • Adjustable from 27.5 to 33 inches.
  • Maximum user weight capacity 300 pounds.

HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #3 Rated

3.8 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category


Our #4 Rated
Bathroom Safety Rail

Carex Health Brands

Bathroom Safety Rail

3.5 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category

Click for price

  • Adjustable free-standing toilet safety rail.
  • Height adjustable up to 33 inches.
  • Maximum user weight capacity 300 pounds.

HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #4 Rated

3.5 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category


Our #5 Rated
Stand-Alone Toilet Rail

Vive

Stand-Alone Toilet Rail

3.3 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category

Click for price

  • Stand-alone one-piece toilet safety rail.
  • Non-adjustable.
  • Maximum user weight capacity 300 pounds.

HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #5 Rated

3.3 out of 5

In the Toilet Safety Rails category

What Are Toilet Safety Rails?

Usually made of tubular metal formed into a frame, toilet safety rails fits on or around—or a combination of the two—the toilet. The frame, some of which are fixed height, while others are adjustable, usually comes up to somewhere around waist height, culminating in a handrail on either side of the toilet.

Some safety rails are completely free standing. Others sit underneath the toilet seat without touching the ground. A third type of toilet safety rail has a mid-height bar that rests on the rear edge of the ceramic toilet bowl and extends to two legs at the front.

If you can’t quite envisage exactly what we’re talking about here, you can find a very informative video below which shows free-standing toilet safety rails in use. Don’t worry, though—the person demonstrating does keep their pants on!

Why Use Toilet Safety Rails?

As one of the many personal care products available, toilet safety rails help to improve stability when using the bathroom. Lowering our bodyweight to the level of the toilet seat requires a squatting movement that actually requires a lot of control and effort from our leg muscles. That’s why the squat is such a popular element of many workout routines.

If we’ve suffered a leg injury, can’t put weight on our foot for some reason, or our balance is poor, it’s very easy to overbalance when squatting. Data from biomechanical research published in the Journal of Biomedical Informatics tells us that using safety rails during toileting can significantly decrease the risk of falling.

This is because when they’re used correctly, toilet safety rails can be used to redistribute some of the person’s bodyweight so that they’re supported by the arms as well as the leg (or legs) that are able to bear weight.

Findings from scientific analysis of squatting like the study published in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research leads us to conclude that toilet safety rails reduce the load on the injured part of the body during a squatting movement. This can reduce pain as well as promoting independence.

Poor balance due to physical disability, a neurological condition such as Parkinson’s disease, and relatively benign but debilitating condition such as dizziness and vertigo are all further reasons why someone might want to use a toilet safety rail.

What to Look for in the Best Toilet Safety Rails

Whichever type you might prefer, the best toilet seat rails have to be sturdy. The last thing anyone needs when relying on these kinds of products to support their body weight is for them to fail. So look for rails with good, solid structures, and check that the maximum weight capacity is appropriate for the user.

If the safety rails are going to be used by different people, it’s probably a good idea to get an adjustable one if you’re dealing with people of dramatically different heights. The same applies if the rails are going to be used in different situations within the home.

Some toilet safety rails are more compact than others. It’s important to check the dimensions of the rails you have in mind for your purpose. Make sure there’s enough room to comfortably fit the frame around the toilet.

Don’t forget to take account of any room the user needs to negotiate their way around the door to enter the bathroom if the toilet is situated near the bathroom door.

If space is at a premium in the bathroom, toilet safety rails that sit on the back of the toilet bowl take up considerably less room than a free-standing frame. Remember to also consider the amount of space the rails will need to the left and right of the toilet.

Precautions for Use

When using toilet safety rails, read the individual manufacturer’s instructions carefully—even if you’ve used a similar product before. In particular, make sure toilet safety rails are placed on a firm, even surface.

Ensure that you always use both handles at the same time when using toilet safety rails to support your weight. Reaching for the rail on only one side can cause the whole structure to tip over.

What Are the Best Toilet Safety Rails?

After hours of research, shopping and consumer testing, the first conclusion we reached is that there are a lot of different toilet safety rails around on the market. Having waded through many of them, we selected five of our best toilet safety rails. We stripped them back to their bare parts to show you the good, the bad and the ugly!

Here are the five best toilet safety rails. We chose some different types to suit different styles and sizes of bathrooms. Have a look at our in-depth reviews which will help you to choose the right product for your needs.

Our #1 Rated
Our pick our #1 rated

Drive Medical

Stand-Alone Toilet Safety Rail

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

This is a very well-designed product which is entirely free standing. It fits around the toilet bowl, and the floor support bar sits very close to the toilet, so it doesn’t get in the way. People found the frame very robust and dependable during use. Lots of people liked the ergonomic design—the handles are angled inwards, which positions them very conveniently for use. Most users found this safety rail easy to assemble—although one or two people did have problems.

People generally found these rails very hygienic and easy to keep clean. Many loved the design, including the integrated magazine rack—perfect for those lengthier bathroom visits! A few users needed to buy a non-slip mat to prevent this frame from slipping on smooth floors. In the main though, people thought that these were good-quality safety rails, but they were also one of the two most expensive.

Pros
Pro Free-standing frame.
Pro No tools required for assembly.
Pro Suitable for standard or elongated toilets.
Pro Padded non-slip hand rails.
Pro Built-in magazine rack.
Cons
Con One or two people had assembly issues.
Con May slip on smooth floors.
 
 
 

Our #2 Rated
Our pick our #2 rated

Medline

Guardian Toilet Safety Rail

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

Medline is a very well-respected company with a solid reputation for good-quality products at reasonable prices. This toilet safety rail is no exception. Many people made lots of positive comments about how neatly this frame fitted around the toilet—it rests on the rear of the ceramic bowl with two legs that extend at each side of the toilet bowl, and most found it really felt safe and reliable to use. People also reported that the padded handrails were very comfortable to use.

In addition to being easy to assemble and use, many people also said these safety rails are very easy to clean. Although most considered them very stable during use, one or two people didn’t find them supportive enough. With numerous positive features, it’s easy to see why so many people were fans. These were also the lowest priced toilet safety rails of the five we reviewed, which most users considered as the icing on the cake.

Pros
Pro Aluminum frame.
Pro Compact.
Pro Lightweight.
Pro Closed-cell foam non-slip armrests.
Pro No tools necessary for assembly.
Pro Easy to relocate if needed.
Cons
Con Not supportive or stable enough for a few people.
 
 
 
 
 

Our #3 Rated
Our pick our #3 rated

Vaunn

Deluxe Safety Toilet Rail

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

This product from a well-respected supplier of personal care equipment was very popular with a lot of users. It’s a stand-alone frame that can be placed over the toilet to provide secure support bars at either side of the user. There were a great many positive comments about how easy this frame was to assemble, but one or two people had problems. Many people reported that these safety rails felt very secure to use after hip or knee surgery and for use by older people with mobility difficulties.

Several users commented that these toilet safety rails were very portable, so handy in a situation where use in different bathrooms is required. Overall, the vast majority of people thought this was a great-quality product which was well worth the mid-range price.

Pros
Pro Independent safety rail.
Pro Easy tool-free assembly.
Pro Lightweight.
Pro No installation required.
Pro Can also be used with sinks.
Pro Mid-height support bars for extra stability.
Cons
Con A small number of people had issues with assembly.
 
 
 
 
 

Our #4 Rated
Our pick our #4 rated

Carex Health Brands

Bathroom Safety Rail

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

This is another stand-alone frame that’s placed over the toilet base unit to provide handrails at either side. Most people reported that this was a good, solid frame which they could trust with their bodyweight. Users of this frame after knee surgery said they loved the frame, finding themselves able to trust it even in the very early days after their op. People had confidence in the non-slip rubber castors, and liked the adjustable height.

A few people found that the 20-inch frame width didn’t give them quite enough room to cleanse themselves comfortably, but this wasn’t a problem for the majority of users. This was considered an excellent-quality frame by the vast majority of users, who thought the high price was well justified. For some, though, the cost was too high compared to other similar products.

Pros
Pro Independent frame requires no installation.
Pro Easy to assemble—no tools needed.
Pro Anti-slip feet.
Pro Lightweight and portable.
Pro Very stable.
Cons
Con Not quite wide enough for some users to cleanse comfortably.
 
 
 
 

Our #5 Rated
Our pick our #5 rated

Vive

Stand-Alone Toilet Rail

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

This independent frame from Vive has stabilizing floor support bars, designed to give it a solid feel. The vast majority of people agreed that it works very well, but one or two heavier users felt they needed something with a more sturdy structure. Several people commented on the ease of assembly. Many liked the built-in magazine rack, and found they had plenty of space for cleansing.

People found these rails useful during periods of vertigo, for elderly family members and post injury. Overall there really wasn’t a lot that people didn’t like about this product. As the most expensive of our top five, the biggest drawback with these toilet safety rails is the price. Many people, however, thought that it was money well spent.

Pros
Pro Freestanding.
Pro No tools required for assembly.
Pro Comfort grip non-slip handrails.
Pro Hassle-free cleaning.
Pro Compact for smaller bathrooms.
Pro Very sturdy for most users.
Cons
Con May not feel sturdy enough for heavier users.
 
 
 
 
 

Our Choice

If, for whatever reason—and whether it’s a short-term or long-term problem for you—we’re a little unsteady on our feet, we often need some help. There are many different personal care and support products which can make life infinitely easier. One of the most pressing personal care needs is toileting.

A toilet safety rail is a great device that can instantly give independence and dignity to someone who’s finding squatting a struggle. When you’re depending on equipment to stop you from falling, though, it’s important to make sure the toilet safety rails you choose are high quality, durable and sturdy.

Of the five great products we reviewed, the best toilet safety rails were the Drive Medical Stand-Alone Toilet Safety Rails. These are all-in-one safety rails that fit very neatly around the toilet, and people were generally impressed with how compact yet sturdy they were.

The magazine rack on the side of the frame made it all the more appealing for some users, and people really felt they could rely on the solid frame for support. Suitable for use in most bathroom spaces, and available for a reasonable cost given the quality, this is definitely our top choice for the best toilet safety rails.

Related Posts

Leave a comment

>

Send this to a friend