What is the Best Natural Mascara in 2019?

Mascara defines lashes, enriches eyelash color and makes lashes appear thicker, fuller and longer. When used correctly, mascara can open the eye area, complete your glamorous look and really make your eyes pop!

The news about mascara isn’t all good, however. There are some downsides to traditional mascaras which need to be considered with regard to eyelash health.

Being reasonably new products on the market, natural mascaras may be a bit of a mystery to some people, so it’s time to debunk the myths, explore the world of natural mascara, and find out which is the best natural mascara for you.

Product
Details
Our Rating
Our #1 Rated
Organic Mascara

Physicians Formula

Organic Mascara

5 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category

Click for price
  • 100% Free of Harsh Chemicals
  • Clump-Free, Smudge-Free, Flake-Free
  • Hypoallergenic; Safe for Sensitive Eyes and Contact Lens Wearers
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #1 Rated

5 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category


Our #2 Rated
Premium Organic Mascara

Naturally Rooted

Premium Organic Mascara

4 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category

Click for price
  • BEAUTIFUL LASHES -- NO HARMFUL CHEMICALS -Our mascara is Natural, 85% Organic and it is Cruelty FREE. Our ingredients help to...
  • GREAT FOR SENSITIVE EYES - Our mascara is Paraben FREE, Dye FREE, Gluten FREE, & Dye FREE making it the perfect mascara for...
  • STRENGTHENS & CONDITIONS - Our nourishing formula contains both Chamomile and Sunflower Oil. Both are known for moisturizing...
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #2 Rated

4 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category


Our #3 Rated
Nourishing Mascara

Burt's Bees

Nourishing Mascara

4 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category

Click for price
  • BLACK MASCARA: One mascara tube with convenient, easy-to-use applicator in Black, perfect for all eye colors and skin tones
  • NOURISHING INGREDIENTS: 100% natural origin formula is made with Jojoba Oil and naturally moisturizing Glycerin which is...
  • STRENGTHEN & CONDITION: Our brush and formula work together to instantly give you long-lasting definition and softly nourish...
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #3 Rated

4 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category


Our #4 Rated
Natural Organic Mascara

Endlessly Beautiful

Natural Organic Mascara

3 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category

Click for price
  • MAKES LASHES LOOK LONGER AND FULLER - Volumizing mascara that goes on smoothly without clumps, flakes, or smudges. This great...
  • ALL NATURAL ORGANIC MAKEUP - This mascara is non toxic and free of harmful chemicals. It is the best mascara for sensitive...
  • STAYS ON ALL DAY - This long lasting lengthening mascara is water resistant and sweat proof. It is is easy to apply and easy...
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #4 Rated

3 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category


Our #5 Rated
Natural Black Mascara

Ecco Bella

Natural Black Mascara

3 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category

Click for price
  • You'll love the defined, full lash fringe you get with our gentle FlowerColor Natural Mascara
  • Feel good and look great with our vegan, gluten free, fragrance free and paraben free mascara
  • Comes with a mirror on each tube for easy application. Gentle on the eyes and easy to remove
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #5 Rated

3 out of 5

In the Natural Mascara category

What Is Natural Mascara?

Unsurprisingly, natural mascaras are made using all-natural ingredients. They avoid all of the potentially toxic substances which can be present in traditional mascaras.

Unfortunately, it’s taken a while for companies to develop mascaras with all-natural ingredients that are able to compete in terms of performance with more traditional non-natural products.

Why Use Natural Mascara?

Many of the non-natural mascaras contain ingredients and chemicals which, long term, can damage eyelashes, making them drier and more brittle, and making them prone to falling out.

Many people are now turning to natural mascara, which is generally much kinder to your lashes and can keep them looking good as well as keeping them healthy.

Free of harsh chemicals, natural mascaras do a great job of assisting you to keep your lashes in tip-top condition, and some can perform almost as well as regular mascaras.

Not only are they kinder to your eyelashes; natural mascaras are also much kinder to the environment.

Precautions for Use

As with any product applied to the body, allergic reaction or irritation is possible, even with natural ingredients.

If you notice any adverse symptoms, such as pain, stinging, burning, redness or swelling, stop using any new products immediately and seek prompt medical advice.

What Is the Best Natural Mascara?

Our #1 Rated
Our pick our #1 rated

Physicians Formula

Organic Mascara

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

With a leaf-shaped handle to the application wand, and the cream colored bottle, this mascara stands out from the crowd from the word go. People were impressed with the strong color, smooth application and no clumping. Many felt a moisturizing effect on the lashes, although a few people found it didn’t take much for this mascara to smear or run.

In general, though, most users liked this product. Many commented that this was a very affordable solution for those who want natural mascara, which isn’t surprising as it was the lowest priced mascara of all those reviewed.

Pros
Pro 0.26 fluid ounce.
Pro 100 percent natural and chemical free.
Pro Hypoallergenic.
Pro Recyclable eco-brush.
Pro Suitable for sensitive eyes.
Pro Non-clumping.
Pro Moisturizes lashes.
Pro Cruelty free.
Cons
Con Can run or smudge easily.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Our #2 Rated
Our pick our #2 rated

Naturally Rooted

Premium Organic Mascara

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

This natural, nourishing mascara was very popular, with some people reporting that it was the best natural mascara they’ve ever tried. Users found it left their lashes in great condition, and thought the application brush worked well.

Some people found they had to apply several layers in quick succession to get their desired look, and some found that their mascara dried out surprisingly quickly. Overall, though, people thought this was a good natural option at a good price.

Pros
Pro 100 percent natural.
Pro 85 percent organic ingredients.
Pro Gluten free.
Pro Strengthens and conditions.
Pro Enriched with chamomile and sunflower oil.
Pro Suitable for those with a sensitive eye area.
Pro Cruelty free.
Cons
Con Can be tricky to apply.
 
 
 
 
 
 

Our #3 Rated
Our pick our #3 rated

Burt's Bees

Nourishing Mascara

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

Burt’s Bees has established a great reputation over the last few years, and people had a lot of good things to say about this mascara. People liked the rich colors, the ease of application and the fact that it didn’t smudge as readily as other mascaras, and was easy to clean up when it did.

A few people thought this product was too thick or dry, and had difficulty applying it without clumping. The vast majority, though, just loved this mascara and thought it was great value.

Pros
Pro 0.4 fluid ounce.
Pro 100 percent natural.
Pro Lengthens and defines lashes.
Pro Enriched with jojoba oil and glycerin.
Pro Two colors—classic black and black brown.
Pro Cruelty free.
Cons
Con A few people found this mascara too thick or dry.
 
 
 
 
 

Our #4 Rated
Our pick our #4 rated

Endlessly Beautiful

Natural Organic Mascara

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

Endlessly Beautiful prides itself on producing natural, cruelty-free makeup. This mascara was very popular with lots of users, even those with sensitive eyes. Some people commented that this was the most gentle mascara they’d ever used, and it didn’t smudge or flake.

Most users commented on the easy, smooth application, although some said this took a little longer than for other mascaras they’d used. People were impressed with the length and volume this mascara gave to their lashes. The only downsides were that a small percentage of users reported an allergic reaction, and a few people commented on the high cost.

Pros
Pro 100 percent natural.
Pro 85 percent organic.
Pro Made in the US.
Pro Suitable for vegans.
Pro Gluten free.
Pro Long-lasting.
Pro Water resistant.
Pro Cruelty free.
Pro Available in two colors—black and brown.
Pro Thirty day money back guarantee.
Pro 100 percent refund promise.
Cons
Con A small number of users had an allergic reaction.
Con High cost.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Our #5 Rated
Our pick our #5 rated

Ecco Bella

Natural Black Mascara

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

Most people found this mascara stays in place well without smudging, but it’s not waterproof, and will run if your eyes weep—as with many other similar products. Many users loved the fullness and length that this mascara added to their lashes, although one or two people found this look hard to achieve, commenting that the mascara was too thin, or clumpy.

Some users commented on how easy this mascara is to apply, though and some felt the application wand wasn’t good quality. Others were impressed with the ease of taking it off at the end of the day.

Pros
Pro 0.38 fluid ounce.
Pro 100 percent natural.
Pro Made in the US.
Pro Suitable for vegans.
Pro Gluten free.
Pro Fragrance free.
Pro Paraben free.
Pro Compact mirror on mascara tube.
Pro 10 percent of company profits go to the Friends of Animals charity.
Pro 100 percent manufacturer’s guarantee.
Cons
Con One or two users reported this mascara as either too thin or clumpy.
Con Some people didn’t like the application wand.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Our Choice

There’s something reassuring about using natural products on your skin and hair, and they’re better quality than ever before. All of our chosen natural mascaras impressed the majority of users.

The one that really stood out—and had a similar effect on people’s eyelashes—was the Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100 Percent Natural Origin Mascara. People were impressed with this product due to the rich, smooth mascara that was easy to apply, and didn’t clump at all.

Consumers also felt it really stood the test of time well, and commented on the lack of flaking when correctly applied. Add in the excellent value for money, and it’s easy to see why this mascara came out on top as the best natural mascara.

Related Posts

Leave a comment

Leave a Comment

Send this to a friend