What is the Best Drugstore Concealer in 2019?

We have all had those mornings when we wake up, look in the mirror and think “When did I turn into a zombie?”.  At that moment we want to reach into our makeup bag and grab that ever-so-handy tube of concealer. Whether going to work, the gym, a day out with the family or friends, even just going shopping we want to put our face on so people don’t stare at us like an extra from a Michael Jackson video.

Sound familiar to you?

Concealer can be one of your best friends when it comes to covering up blemishes or those tell-tale dark circles around the eyes following a late night. The best concealers can brighten up your face, while the wrong one can make you look like that previously mentioned monster from the Thriller video. The trick is to choose a concealer that makes you look more alive and one that matches the tone of your skin.

The best concealers can cover discolorations, lighten dark areas, disguise blemishes and work in combination with your foundation to help even the skin tone. A poorly formulated concealer or one you apply incorrectly will only draw attention to any problem areas, make blemishes more noticeable and create lighter areas around dark circles especially under the eyes.

Here’s the kicker.

While there’s no denying that many of the more expensive department store or salon concealers do a great job, fortunately there are now many drugstore cosmetic brands available. Various different formulas can also give natural-looking coverage while leaving you with enough money leftover for that next night out. Concealers are one of the biggest selling and most used makeup products with 2017 statistics showing over 102 million women in the US used either concealer or foundation.

If you’re looking for that new best friend, a reliable concealer that stays put from the moment you blend it on, we’ve rounded up some of the best drugstore concealers to cover up those dark circles and spots. For maximum coverage, it’s always useful to have a few concealers in your beauty kit and that’s where the best drugstore concealers come in handy. With most being under $10—one we looked at was even under $5—you can afford to purchase and mix multiple shades.

Product
Details
Our Rating
Our #1 Rated
Fit Me! Concealer

Maybelline

Fit Me! Concealer

5 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category

Click for price
  • MAYBELLINE CONCEALER: With 12 shades, this oil-free concealer matches skin tones to deliver a more even complexion, with a...
  • A SHADE THAT FITS ME: Maybelline Fit Me liquid concealer provides coverage for a wide array of skin tones, from Fair to...
  • MAYBELLINE FIT ME FOR A FLAWLESS FACE: With Dewy+ Smooth foundation with SPF 18, Matte + Poreless foundation, concealer,...
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #1 Rated

5 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category


Our #2 Rated
Super-Blendable Concealer

L'Oréal

Super-Blendable Concealer

4 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category

Click for price
  • Super Blendable Concealer
  • Covers imperfections
  • Evens Skintone and Restores Brightness
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #2 Rated

4 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category


Our #3 Rated
Makeup Concealer Wand

NYX

Makeup Concealer Wand

4 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category

Click for price
  • HD PHOTOGENIC CONCEALER: Our HD Studio Photogenic Concealer in Fair smoothly covers blemishes, imperfections, skin...
  • COLOR-CORRECTING COVERAGE: Available in 23 shades including color-correcting green, yellow, and lavender, providing natural...
  • FACE FROM FOUNDATION TO FINISH: Complete your makeup look with our full line of NYX Professional Makeup face products to aid...
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #3 Rated

4 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category


Our #4 Rated
Instaready Concealer

Physicians Formula

Instaready Concealer

4 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category

Click for price
  • Correct & cover imperfections instantly
  • Multipurpose, creamy concealer
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #4 Rated

4 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category


Our #5 Rated
Concealer & Highlighter

e.l.f.

Concealer & Highlighter

4 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category

Click for price
  • Misc.
HealthAmbition Stamp

Our #5 Rated

4 out of 5

In the Drugstore Concealer category

How to Choose the Best Concealer for You?

When looking for a concealer that works for you, it’s not only the shade you have to consider, but also what works for your skin type and any concerns you may have.

For starters:

If your skin is of the dry type, avoid choosing a liquid concealer with a matte finish as the result will only emphasize the dryness of your skin. If you have oily skin or combination skin with larger pores, don’t go for a creamy or stick type of concealer as they tend to clog the pores (making the pores appear larger) and can leave an oily shine to the skin. It sounds obvious but you’d be amazed at how often we girls can get it wrong!

Beyond that:

A light to medium coverage concealer will help create a more even finish if you suffer minor skin discolorations. For darker under eye areas, you should always try to select a shade of concealer no more than one or two shades lighter than your natural tone to avoid those dreaded white circles around the eyes.

For your face in general, select a shade of concealer that matches the foundation you’ll be using. Concealer shades that are more pink, rose, peach, white or yellow and color correcting shades of green or purple may show through your foundation creating an unnatural look.

This Youtube video talks about which type of foundation is best for your skin type and choosing the right shade:

What Is the Best Drugstore Concealer?

Although you could just go to a high-end department store and have a consultation with one of the professional specialists on each product’s stands, but why bother? Remember they’re employed to sell a specific product, typically more expensive than many of the brands easily available online or at your local drugstore. (Somebody must pay their wages, beauticians don’t come cheap)!

We’ve looked at many of the top selling drugstore concealers, all from leading brand names we’ve grown to trust, to bring you what we consider five of the best drugstore concealers.

Let’s jump in.

Our #1 Rated
Our pick our #1 rated

Maybelline

Fit Me! Concealer

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

This lightweight concealer from one of the drugstore industry leaders, Maybelline, offers full coverage yet is surprisingly hydrating. Many customers say it’s an exact copy of the iconic Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer, but at half the price. An exclusive translucent base with lightweight pigments allows the skin’s natural highs and lows to shine through.

Maybelline uses no waxes or oils in this product which is also non-comedogenic to avoid clogging those pores. It’s been tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists for safe use around the eyes and is fragrance-free—always a bonus for something you apply around the nostrils. A wider choice of colors than was previously available now means even more people can try this quality product from Maybelline and enjoy it’s flawless finish formula. Many customers find this concealer is one of the best for unrelenting dark circles with no irritation or discomfort in the eye area.

Pros
Pro Inexpensive quality lightweight concealer that offers long lasting hydration.
Pro More shades mean it’s suitable for most skin tones
Pro including both lighter and darker hues.
Pro Very light without being sheer yet covers dark spots or circles well.
Pro Doesn’t crease.
Pro Buildable and blends well
Pro doesn’t cake.
Pro Provided wand is great for non-messy application.
Pro Ideal for very pale girls.
Pro Lasts all day with seven to eight hours longevity.
Cons
Con Women with oily skin have found the product settles into fine lines after a few hours.
Con Deep or darker complexions may find even the darker shades don’t conceal well.
Con Needs foundation or primer base to highlight or illuminate on many skin tones.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Our #2 Rated
Our pick our #2 rated

L'Oréal

Super-Blendable Concealer

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

This concealer from L’Oréal, as the name suggests, has been made to match your skin. Available in nine different shades, the True Match concealer offers a super blendable formula to keep your skin looking both natural and blemish free. This concealer evens the skin tone and restores brightness for all skin tones and undertones—there’s even a range of True Match blendable makeup with a micro-fine powder for more coverage, a super blendable blush and a crayon-style concealer available.

If you have more of a medium skin tone and are looking to correct dark circles yet retain that natural look it’s hard to beat this natural formula. The concealer easily blends with your fingertips and will stay put for around six hours once set with a powder. For a more professional-looking application use a concealer brush to blend. A translucent powder dusted on top will set the concealer and prolong the wear.

Pros
Pro Various shades designed to precisely match your skin tones.
Pro Buildable
Pro natural coverage to hide imperfections
Pro even your skin tone and restore brightness.
Pro Concealer is easy to blend and goes on smooth.
Pro Super pigmented
Pro good for covering zits or general redness.
Cons
Con Colors can be transferable to other makeup
Con very rich pigments means too much applied will show through other products.
Con Some customers have reported it settling into fine lines throughout the day.
Con Formula can crease.
Con Lighter shades found to be too dark by very fair skins.
Con Many customers have found this not to be the best concealer for dark circles.
 

Our #3 Rated
Our pick our #3 rated

NYX

Makeup Concealer Wand

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

Don’t let the price fool you with this concealer wand, this budget concealer cream has won many awards, including the Allure 2015 Best of Beauty Award and yet can be found for around the $5 mark. Available in a wide choice of 20 skin-correcting shades it’s a drugstore concealer that’ll counteract the discoloration present in the face and neutralize it. (There are even green, yellow and purple versions for color correcting).

The richly pigmented formula provides long-lasting wear and will cover even the most stubborn blemishes or dark circles with ease. The cream is infused with hydrators and skin-conditioning agents, yet many customers have said it’s ideal for use on oily skin, with a non-comedogenic formula that won’t clog pores. Lasting between eight to ten hours, the compact size and easy wand applicator mean it fits in even the smallest of bags if you should require a touch up. As the name suggests, this concealer looks really good on photos too.

Pros
Pro Wide choice of both nude and color-correcting shades to choose from.
Pro Doesn’t cake up
Pro rich cream is easy to blend.
Pro Suitable for oily or combination skin.
Pro Can also be used as a highlighter.
Pro Long-lasting coverage.
Pro Compact with easy to use application wand.
Pro Ideal for use in photography.
Cons
Con Some colors can appear too strong if not applied properly.
Con Can cling to drier patches of skin or sink into some creases.
Con Green color correcting shade is VERY green with one customer referring to it as “Shrek green”—nice!
 
 
 
 
 

Our #4 Rated
Our pick our #4 rated

Physicians Formula

Instaready Concealer

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

Physicians Formula may not be as well known as some major drugstore cosmetics brands although many of us girls swear by their products. Instaready Full Coverage concealer is not only lightweight and long lasting but also comes with an SPF 30 sunscreen included. Simple to apply with the included sponge, it gives the coverage of a stick in liquid form in a mess-free pump dispenser bottle.

It may be at the top of the drugstore concealer price range but this semi-matte concealer can help keep blotchiness, zits and acne scars under cover all day. Light reflective spherical beads, color-filter pigments and high-tech polymers work together to instantly mattify, blur imperfections and retexturize the skin while also protecting against UVA/UVB damage from the sun. A hypoallergenic, paraben-free, fragrance-free and dermatologically tested formula is safe enough to use around sensitive eye areas, with the baby sponge making it easy enough to sheer out any excess concealer around your eyes.

Pros
Pro Offers some of the most complete coverage from a drugstore concealer
Pro that also lasts for hours.
Pro Multipurpose
Pro can be used to cover blemishes or around the eyes as a brightener.
Pro Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Pro Choice of three shades
Pro fair
Pro light and medium.
Pro Included blending sponge.
Pro High SPF 30
Pro ideal for those summer months
Pro although extended exposure to strong sunlight sometimes requires more frequent application of sunscreen.
Pro Hypoallergenic.
Pro Paraben free.
Pro Fragrance free.
Pro Gluten free.
Pro Cruelty free and clinically tested.
Cons
Con Pump dispenser has been known to gush.
Con Can look a bit cakey
Con especially around the eyes and side of the nose.
Con Too oily for many customers
Con better for use on normal to dry skin types.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Our #5 Rated
Our pick our #5 rated

e.l.f.

Concealer & Highlighter

  • Quality
    Quality

  • Quality
    Price

  • Quality
    Our rating

For those late nights out we all occasionally enjoy, this under eye concealer from e.l.f. Studio can help hide dark circles and bags the morning after. Vitamins A and E are combined with chamomile, caffeine and green tea extract to moisturize, soothe and tighten the skin around your delicate eyes. This concealer is also known to blend in easily for a smooth, natural finish.

As a highlight cream, it offers an instant brightening boost with light-reflective pigments that aim to work like an instant eye lift. You could also use the product as a base for your eyeshadow. Simply dot the formula and then blend in under, around and on the top of your eye area for a youthful glow. The concealer offers a choice of three shades, light, medium and fair to ensure you get the right level of glow for your eye.

Pros
Pro A true multipurpose makeup
Pro as it works both as a concealer and highlighter.
Pro Blends easily and evenly
Pro no streaks.
Pro Offers excellent value for money.
Pro Compact size to fit in the smallest of purses.
Pro Offers good coverage
Pro customers report only using six to eight drops for full coverage.
Pro Works on even the darkest eye circles.
Cons
Con Some users have complained the concealer is too sheer for under their eyes
Con often drawing attention to the eye area
Con trying a different shade may solve the problem.
Con Consistency can be too watery
Con you can take it off when applying foundation on top.
Con Only lasts four to five hours.
Con Not hypoallergenic with some customers finding it irritated their skin.
 
 

Our Choice

Choosing the right concealer for your skin tone can often be a confusing purchase. Although many of the drugstore brands now offer countless shades to match the hue of your skin, certain products may be too heavily pigmented. This means they may not work with other makeup you wear or just won’t provide enough coverage for dark circles or imperfections of the skin.

Buying a quality concealer no longer involves a trip to expensive department stores, there are many drugstore concealers than can do the same job at a fraction of the price. For the quality of product, choice of skin tones available from a brand many of us already use, trust and even love, the Maybelline New York Fit Me! Concealer is in our opinion the best drugstore concealer you can buy, and at a bargain price too.

Related Posts

Leave a comment

Leave a Comment

Send this to a friend